Upper lid blepharoplasty, or upper eyelid surgery, is a popular procedure designed to address drooping and excess skin of upper eyelids. While this surgery is often associated with cosmetic enhancement, it is also frequently performed for medical reasons. Depending on the underlying cause for the surgery, the approach, benefits, and insurance coverage can differ significantly. In this blog, we will explore the differences between medical and cosmetic upper lid blepharoplasty, how to determine which is right for you, and what to expect from each type of procedure.
What Is Upper Lid Blepharoplasty?
Upper lid blepharoplasty is a surgical procedure that involves removing excess skin, muscle, and sometimes fat from the upper eyelids. Over time, the skin around the eyes can lose its elasticity, causing it to sag and create a hooded or droopy appearance. This condition, known as ptosis, can have both aesthetic and functional implications.
In some cases, the drooping is primarily a cosmetic concern, affecting a person’s appearance by making them look tired or older than they feel. In other cases, the sagging skin may interfere with vision, particularly in the peripheral fields, making upper lid blepharoplasty a medical necessity.
Medical Upper Lid Blepharoplasty
Medical upper lid blepharoplasty is performed to correct functional issues caused by excessive sagging of the upper eyelid skin. This is more than just a cosmetic concern; it can significantly impact a person’s quality of life. The most common medical indication for this surgery is visual impairment due to the upper eyelid skin folding over the lash line and blocking peripheral vision. Patients often report difficulty seeing out of the corners of their eyes, trouble reading, or challenges with everyday tasks like driving.
In these cases, an ophthalmologist or plastic surgeon may recommend medical blepharoplasty to restore a clear line of sight. Here’s a breakdown of the key features of medical blepharoplasty:
Who Needs Medical Blepharoplasty?
Medical upper lid blepharoplasty is typically performed on patients experiencing:
Visual field obstruction: When the drooping skin interferes with peripheral vision.
Irritation or discomfort: Excess skin can cause discomfort, making the eyelids feel heavy or difficult to open.
Eye fatigue or strain: Patients may unconsciously use their forehead muscles to lift their eyelids, leading to headaches or eye strain.
Recurrent infections: In some cases, excess skin can trap moisture, leading to irritation or infections in the folds of the eyelid.
Insurance Coverage for Medical Blepharoplasty
Because medical upper lid blepharoplasty is deemed necessary to restore proper vision, it is often covered by insurance. However, to qualify for coverage, patients must undergo tests like visual field exams, which document the degree of obstruction caused by the drooping eyelids. If the results show that the excess skin is impairing vision, insurance may cover part or all of the cost of the surgery.
Benefits of Medical Blepharoplasty
Improved vision: The primary goal of medical blepharoplasty is to restore normal vision, allowing patients to see more clearly and safely.
Alleviated discomfort: Patients often experience relief from headaches, eye strain, or the feeling of heaviness in the eyelids.
Enhanced appearance: Although the main objective is functional, patients also benefit from a more youthful and alert appearance after surgery.
Cosmetic Upper Lid Blepharoplasty
On the other hand, cosmetic upper lid blepharoplasty is performed purely for aesthetic reasons. As we age, the skin loses elasticity, and fat deposits around the eyes can shift, causing a tired, hooded, or saggy look. Even if vision isn’t affected, many people seek upper lid blepharoplasty to enhance their appearance and restore a more youthful look to their eyes.
Who Seeks Cosmetic Blepharoplasty?
Cosmetic upper lid blepharoplasty is sought by patients who:
Feel their eyes look tired or aged: Drooping eyelids can make someone look tired or older, even if they feel rested.
Desire a more open, refreshed appearance: The goal is to brighten the eyes, giving the face a more awake and youthful look.
Have asymmetrical eyelids: Some patients may have one eyelid that droops more than the other, causing facial imbalance.
Want to enhance their overall facial aesthetics: The eyes are a central feature of the face, and improving their appearance can dramatically alter one’s look.
Insurance Coverage for Cosmetic Blepharoplasty
Since cosmetic blepharoplasty is performed solely for aesthetic reasons, it is not covered by insurance. Patients must pay for the procedure out-of-pocket, but many find that the improvement in appearance and self-confidence is well worth the investment.
Benefits of Cosmetic Blepharoplasty
Youthful appearance: The most obvious benefit is a more youthful, refreshed look.
Boosted confidence: Many patients report feeling more confident and satisfied with their appearance after cosmetic eyelid surgery.
Subtle, natural results: When performed by an experienced surgeon, cosmetic blepharoplasty can deliver subtle and natural-looking results, making the eyes look more open without an overdone or "surgical" appearance.
Differences Between Medical and Cosmetic Blepharoplasty
While both medical and cosmetic upper lid blepharoplasty procedures aim to remove excess skin and rejuvenate the eyelids, the primary distinction lies in the purpose of the surgery. Medical blepharoplasty is done to restore proper vision, while cosmetic blepharoplasty is performed to improve appearance.
Another key difference is in insurance coverage. Medical blepharoplasty may be covered by insurance if it’s necessary to improve vision, whereas cosmetic procedures are considered elective and are not covered. The surgical techniques used may be similar, but the outcomes and motivations differ significantly.
Upper lid blepharoplasty can provide significant benefits, whether performed for medical or cosmetic reasons. For those experiencing vision impairment due to sagging eyelids, medical blepharoplasty offers functional relief and is often covered by insurance. For others looking to rejuvenate their appearance, cosmetic blepharoplasty offers a refreshed, more youthful look. Both types of surgery are safe and effective when performed by a skilled surgeon like Dr Theo Birch, and the decision should be based on individual needs and goals.
Contact us today should you have any further questions or want to explore your options.
Why Choose Dr Theo Birch for Your Blepahroplasty?
Dr. Theo Birch’s expertise in blepharoplasty, combined with his personalised approach, ensures that each patient receives the highest standard of care. Whether performing blepharoplasty for upper or lower eyelids, Dr. Birch is dedicated to achieving results that enhance both function and appearance. His commitment to using advanced techniques and providing comprehensive post-operative support helps to ensure a smooth and successful recovery process.
Contact our clinic today to take the first step towards achieving a more
confident and comfortable you.
Jade Chapman – Nurse Practitioner
Comments